Blog Discussion Thread: Economic Theory to the causes of the Great Depression & its ultimate demise



D. Micheals Campbell

HIUS 713-D01 

American Entrepreneurship since 1900

Liberty University

Nov 2024

Professor Corey Roberts

    Blog Discussion Thread: Economic Theory to the causes of the Great Depression & its ultimate demise

President Herbert Hoover was the commander in chief when the stock market crashed in October of 1929. Yet for several months he had some time to head off the upcoming disturbing situation. According to Mr. Milkis' book he just needed to pull the trigger. “Early in his presidency, Hoover called a special session of Congress to recommend a significant program of reform.”1 This call for an April 1929 special session proceeded to set things off in a way of significant change according to Mr. Nelson. “Hoover called for major changes in tariffs, taxes, conservation, and government organization. He urged Congress to develop programs to deal with the nation’s stubborn depression in agriculture.”2 President Hoover had the mindset to put these people all in a room and let nature take its course.

     According to Mr. Milkis, President Hoover was someone that felt that as President he should be just an ideas man. “Hoover also believed that his administration should mobilize industrial and civic organizations to facilitate better economic coordination and enhanced economic opportunities.”3 Being an ideas man is good but (according to Mr. Nelson’s research) the one thing President Hoover lacked was not just the gathering of ideas and people but the leadership to execute the eventual plan in earnest. “Hoover’s refusal to lead the special session of Congress that he called in 1929 tempered the widespread enthusiasm that had greeted his election.”4 

     This poor leadership of a President of the United States put forth a man in charge who is willing to have ideas, put those people in a room but just sit back and automatically assume that if he observes everything from a corner that it would work itself out but this was not the case at all. Thus like a house of cards things then over the next couple of months begin to  fall apart. The bubble slowly began to burst (in October 25,1929)  but according to the Washington Times ( a few days earlier) no one in the federal government was (quite literally) worried. “Confident the gigantic business structure of the nation stands untouched by the New York stock market break and may even benefit through easier money, a half dozen proposals to prevent a recurrence of speculation orgies were being prepared for action in the Senate.”5 Financial advisor Mr. Kuhns of the Daily Empire felt the same. “Investment trusts are “strong hands,” in Wall Street's colorful vernacular.”6 “When stocks are in strong hands it means that they are held by individuals and groups who have Capital enough to live through a sharp decline their securities wildly on the market”7 Mr. Kuhns also felt that people were getting up in arms about nothing. “With investment thrusts, each backed by millions in capital, conducting a bulk speculation, market authorities see less and less possibility of the bottom dropping out of the market.”8 The Daily Worker pretty much stated the obvious which was in fact ignored by other publications of the day. “The greatest stock market crash in history became even more serious yesterday than on either Thursday or Monday, in spite of the frantic efforts of J.P. Morgan and the largest banks to halt the panic on the stock exchange which has resulted from the business recession.”9                 


     There was always a lot of assumption, speculation or disagreement as to how this tornado of an issue ( which dropped onto the people of America like a bomb)  eventually happened on this day however Theresa Gambacorta measured out all the problems President Hoover can across and narrowed it down to a few well versed yet logical answers. “Scholars agree that exuberant and unregulated speculation—with citizens from all economic backgrounds having access to easy credit lines to borrow money to buy stocks “ on margin”  –and a drought that caused an agricultural crisis, were two major contributors to the “ Black Tuesday ” stock market crash on Oct. 29,1929; by Dec. 1, New York Stock Exchange stocks had lost $26 billion in value; within a year nearly 1,300 banks closed.”10 

     When writing about the ultimate demise of the Great Depression it sure as hell was not President Hoover that started the ball rolling in that direction according to Andrew Roberts. “The Speed with which Roosevelt put the United States economy on a war footing rivaled that with which he had installed his New Deal

programme after his inauguration in 1933.”11 The 32nd President of the United States stuck to his word


about changing America's current state and began to pull out tricks out his bag in an attempt to put things


back into perspective. Mr. Roberts states how this man did the complete opposite of staying in place,


President Hoover. “Authorian planning of the mighty American economy was policed by a sea of regulatory


authorities known by their acronyms, which managed almost every area of what effectively became a state-


capitalist system.”12 Although President Roosevelt was not ( at the moment) making an actual dent in the


American economy, it was ( according to Mr. Roberts) this breakneck attitude ( also a few upcoming World


War 2 American industrial productions ) which led things into a more solid direction. “Taxation was used to


hold maximum after -tax salaries to $25,000; a freeze was introduced on commercial, farm and commodity


prices, which under the Emergency Price Control Act would be fixed by the Office of Price Administration;


wages and rents were simile controlled; widespread rationing was imposed; consumer credit was mercilessly


squeezed; war profiteering was aggressively combated; synthetic-rubber production was so increased that by


1945 the United States was making more of it than the entire global pre-1939 production of natural


rubber.”13 Things took time and while a lot of people were worried about whether President Roosevelt was


making any headway apparently people kept the faith which is why 4 years later he was reelected.  

Based on the (detailed) well researched information Mr. Jean Edward Smith found out that although the Great depression was still happening things were slowly turning over for Americans in 1937.

      “In the spring of 1937 American production pulled above pre-Depression levels for the first time. The New York Times’ Weekly Business Index reported output at 110—10 percent higher than in the corresponding week in 1929.”14 These incredible changes within America really showcased the difference of a non-existent leadership role in which President Hoover apparently operated during his period in office versus President Roosevelt’s take the bull by the horns attitude. A slew of other things (Lend-lease program, Pearl Harbor and a heavy amount of American industrial production) happened which changed things. What Mr. Roberts gets to the bottom of the facts ( in his book) is that as a leader President Roosevelt pushed people to think outside the box. 

     “In January 1942, Roosevelt presented a $59 billion budget to Congress, 52 billion of which was devoted to military expenditure, in the same month that the sale of new cars and passenger trucks was banned by the Office of Production Management ( which is why there is no such thing as a 1943-model American motor car).”15 By doing this President Roosevelt set the standard that if we are in trouble perhaps we work hard within our own country and do something about it. According to Mr. Roberts there were two battles happening that indeed called for Americans to fight for their lives. “ Roosevelt sent the American economy into battle, with results that the German and Japanese production figures could not hope to match. By the end of the war, the USA had provided for her allies 37,000 tanks, 800,000 trucks, two million rifles.”16 This attitude ( because of a dedication to get back on their feet and World War 2) and the leadership of President Roosevelt resulted in the ultimate demise of the Great Depression. 



                

                                                                     Methodology

     The approach here was to follow a relatively honest (historically accurate) look at what caused the Great Depression. A few of the key issues ( throughout the years between 1929 to 1942) which resulted in the eventual ending of the Great Depression. The detailed explanation is to begin with the non-existent flying blind Presidential look at Herbert Clark Hoover from two books that specialized at looking at the (wise or unwise) choices of Presidents. By looking at these two books they both give a pretty good serious look at what he lacked or failed to notice for things throughout his one term. The newspaper which ( as a primary source) provided a more up close and personal directive as to what people were thinking (literally) the day after the stock market crash. The Storm of War, A New History of the Second World War by Andrew Roberts provides a directive of what the war effort did while FDR by Jean Edward Smith gives you a very close look at the decisions of the 32nd President of the United States. Each source gives you a very real look at how things went from nothing going well to the change in the wind due to WW2 which put America’s fortunes in a different light. 

               

                                                                        Analysis

     There are 6 elements to examine ( under the microscope) that put things into a perspective. The first is the decisions of President Hoover. If you look at the first four years under this President he had no idea how to change the current status of America. The second is the choices of President Roosevelt who tried dipping a few things into the frying pan but was not making progress. The third being the 1939 beginnings of World War 2 which changed things slowly for a variety of countries. The fourth being the thrust of America into World War 2 due to the activities of Pearl Harbor even though (quietly) President Roosevelt with the Lend Lease program had already begun to genuinely put forth an option in helping Great Britain while also assisting his own country as well. The fifth being the Industrial Production of everything war related which ignited by the 32nd President led to a significant change. The last being the American people who worked hard and by doing this they put their own future in their own hands thus the reason why they emerged from this murky 13 year hell. If one was to do further analysis you would understand that the elements that significantly put things in a particularly different perspective eventually combined for an abstract conclusion.      


                                                                      Conclusion

     In conclusion, the 1929 October stock market crash hit the Hoover administration like a ton of bricks and he had no answer for it. For (many years) the new 32nd President of the United States floundered for quite some period of time but slowly things began to change which is why he was elected twice more before a miracle did happen. Some miracles are considered good but this miracle was a horrible situation overall. What is sad but true is that it took the actions of Pearl Harbor and the record speed of the american people industrial production in factories creating weapons that ended the Great Depression. The study’s findings basically was that a lot of mismanagement led to the stock market crash but it took ( many years) and the combined acts of World War 2 to right things for the better. The change in leadership from President Hoover to President Roosevelt also helped.     

  

1~Sidney M. Milkis and Michael Nelson. The American Presidency, Origins and Development 1776 -2002. (Washington D.C.: CQ Press, 2003) page 262.

2~Nelson, 262.

3~ Milkis, 262.

4~Nelson, 263.

5~“Government Officials Not Alarmed by Market Panic.”The Washington Times.October 25, 1929.Page 3.

https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn84026749/1929-10-25/ed-1/seq-3/ 

6~  Kuhns, William, Financial Editor. “Investment Trusts are Cushion Against Violent Stock Reactions.”The Daily Empire. (Juneau, Alaska) Oct. 29, 1929. 

 https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn83045499/1929-10-29/ed-1/seq-1/ 


7~ Kuhns, William, Financial Editor. “Investment Trusts are Cushion Against Violent Stock Reactions.”The Daily Empire. (Juneau, Alaska) Oct. 29, 1929. 

 https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn83045499/1929-10-29/ed-1/seq-1/ 

8~  Kuhns, William, Financial Editor. “Investment Trusts are Cushion Against Violent Stock Reactions.”The Daily Empire. (Juneau, Alaska) Oct. 29, 1929. 

 https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn83045499/1929-10-29/ed-1/seq-1/ 

9 ~ “25,000,000,000 IS LOSS AS WALL ST. CRASH GROWS” Greatest Fiscal Crisis in World’s History Gains Momentum. The Daily Worker, Final City Edition, (Chicago, Ill), 30 Oct. 1929.

 https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn84020097/1929-10-30/ed-1/seq-1/  

10 ~ Theresa Gambacorta. “Herbert Clark Hoover, The Depression Was Too Great For Hoover to Overcome.” The United States Presidents, The Best and Worst of All Time.(New York: American Collector, 2020)Page 58.

11~ Andrew Roberts. The Storm of War, A New History of the Second World War. (New York: Harper Perennial, 2011) page 197.

12 ~ Roberts, page 197.

13 ~ Roberts, 197-198.

14 ~ Jean Edward Smith. FDR. (New York: Random House Trade Paperbacks, 2008) Page 396.

15 ~ Roberts, page 198.

16~ Roberts, page 198.                                                                            

  Bibliography/ Sources


“25,000,000,000 IS LOSS AS WALL ST. CRASH GROWS” Greatest Fiscal Crisis in World’s History Gains Momentum. The Daily Worker, Final City Edition, (Chicago, Ill), 30 Oct. 1929.

 https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn84020097/1929-10-30/ed-1/seq-1/  


“Government Officials Not Alarmed by Market Panic.”The Washington Times.October 25, 1929.Page 3.

https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn84026749/1929-10-25/ed-1/seq-3/ 

   

Gambacorta, Theresa. “Herbert Clark Hoover, The Depression Was Too Great For Hoover to Overcome.” The United States Presidents, The Best and Worst of All Time. page 58. New York: American Collector, 2020.


Kuhns, William, Financial Editor. “Investment Trusts are Cushion Against Violent Stock Reactions.”The Daily Empire. (Juneau, Alaska) Oct. 29, 1929. 

 https://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn83045499/1929-10-29/ed-1/seq-1/ 


Milkis, Sidney M. and Michael Nelson. The American Presidency, Origins and Development 1776 -2002. Washington D.C.: CQ Press, 2003.


Roberts, Andrew. The Storm of War, A New History of the Second World War. New York: Harper Perennial, 2011.


Smith, Jean Edward. FDR. New York: Random House Trade Paperbacks, 2008.



 

Comments

  1. This discussion on the economic theories behind the Great Depression offers a clear perspective on how flawed financial systems and policy failures contributed to the crisis. The breakdown of economic models and the insights into recovery strategies make this thread highly informative for learners. For students exploring technical or academic subjects, reliable academic support can make research easier. You can also check out civil engineering assignment help for structured guidance in complex topics.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blog: Option two Local History Assignment: Black Slaves, The British & William Woodford & the Burning of Norfolk, Virginia

Blog Discussion Thread: Economic Influencers between 1900 and 1929 : D. Leroy Dresser